Seriously, you’re going to hurt yourself.

I have three feeds from WOW Insider going: The Queue, The Daily Quest, and anything tagged “priest” (that last one can get really annoying when the authors/editors of, say, All The World’s A Stage decide to spam every possible tag they can on So You Want To Be A Herbalist). Today, in the Priest feed, the Forum Post of the Day came through. It was about Discipline priests in raids, and how a raid leader was singling out a Discipline priest because his healing on the meters was under par. Amanda’s final comment really rang true: “It’s not about being a star, or a prima dona [sic], raiding is about working together as a team to accomplish a common goal.”

This is going to come as news to a lot of raid leaders (go on, raise your hand if you are one), but really and truly, Ulduar is not Galaga. Galaga is about getting the highest possible score; that’s the whole point of the game. Raid leaders tend to treat raiding like it works the same way – they see the healing and DPS meters as high score charts, and penalize raiders who don’t get onto the charts. The problem with that is that unlike Galaga, World of Warcraft raiding actually has a very concrete win condition: did you defeat the boss? If you defeated the boss, the entire raid wins. If not, the entire raid fails.

If the raid isn’t failing – if you’re successfully downing the bosses you want to take down – then there’s no reason at all to single anyone out on the meters. You met the win condition! Clearly everyone is doing at least as well as they need to be, or else you wouldn’t be successful.

If the raid is failing, everybody needs to step up a little more. It’s really tempting to go through the high scores – sorry, the meters – and identify the people who aren’t scoring as high – sorry, doing as much damage or healing – and try to “fix” those people. (In the example in Amanda’s post, the RL asked the priest to go Holy to increase his HPS.) Unfortunately, that simply won’t solve the problem. Unless you’re being actively sabotaged or someone’s doing something incredibly dumb, fixing a single person isn’t going to make the raid go from not killing the boss to killing the boss. When a raid fails, nobody is exempt. If the raid isn’t doing enough DPS but the healing is okay, the healers can look at ways to keep the raid alive a little longer after the enrage timer hits, or to damage the boss between heals. If the raid is doing enough DPS but important players are dying, the DPS can work on staying out of the fire or taking the adds down a little faster. I don’t mean that the DPS is exempt from improving in the first scenario or the healers are exempt in the second; I mean that everybody shares the responsibility of a failed attempt.

(If you are being actively sabotaged or someone’s doing something incredibly dumb, the meters aren’t going to help you anyway.)

I’m not saying that meters are useless. The best – perhaps the only valid – use of meters is to check your own performance in the raid (and even then it’s not necessarily accurate, like the Discipline priest example above, which is why WOW Web Stats is handy), and to look at other raid members to see what you could be doing differently. Raid leaders, though, should be paying attention not at individual raiders – because I will guarantee that there isn’t a single player in the raid who can’t improve something – but at the statistics of the raid as a whole. It’s obvious, but damaging to the egos of the other raiders, that if you think a single person is holding you back enough that you can identify them as the cause of your wipes, it’s actually the whole rest of the raid that needs work.

Be Sociable, Share!

No related posts.

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.